New carry gun.........

Mills · 01-07-2016, 21:51

Well guys, new years resolution complete.

I quit using Copenhagen.

I think I deserve a new gun.

It seems to be a toss up between the M&P Shield 9mm and the Glock 42 (.380). I have heard mixed reviews on both, however I have heard of more mechanical issues with the Glock 42. The M&P Shield complaints seem to be standard based on people that might prefer the XD or the Glock. I like that the shield has a safety so that the wife could have it in the purse from time to time as well.

Anyone have experience with either?

if I can't decide, I might be just going with the S&W .38 snubnose.

RomanCandle · 01-08-2016, 03:21

If I may ask why M&P 9mm vs Glock 42 .380? What about the Glock 43 that offers 9mm in the same size?

JJ_BPK · 01-08-2016, 07:07

I would stay with the 9mm vs the 380 if all other factors are even.

Fist size seems to be one of the 1st go-nogo tests. A lot of people don't like 1.5 or 2 finger grips.

You might also look at the new SIG swappable frame P250..

http://www.sigsauer.com/CatalogProdu...tols-p250.aspx

ADDED: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EbfC4Qw8Vu0

Streck-Fu · 01-08-2016, 07:36

In similar sized weapons, I see zero advantage in .380 over 9mm as it is a lower power round and more expensive to shoot.

UWOA (RIP) · 01-08-2016, 08:31

Quote:

Originally Posted by Streck-Fu

In similar sized weapons, I see zero advantage in .380 over 9mm as it is a lower power round and more expensive to shoot.

What he said ....

.

DIYPatriot · 01-08-2016, 09:07

I have several stun guns (9mm) as TS calls them, a couple .40's and a couple .45's - wish I had NEVER bought a 380. It's like the redheaded stepchild that rarely gets fed. Several of my friends have the G43 and love it. A couple carry the Shield and really like it as well. Guess my thoughts are to stick with 9mm if you have other 9mm guns. 380 ammo is overpriced in my neck of the woods, anyway.

By the way...all my buddies got a decent little discount with the Glock blue label program. Not sure if that might persuade you. It knocked $100 off the purchase price.

https://us.glock.com/bluelabel

**Box** · 01-08-2016, 09:38

I just bought a Ruger LCR in 9mm.
I like it a lot.

DIYPatriot · 01-08-2016, 10:26

Quote:

Originally Posted by Billy L-bach

I just bought a Ruger LCR in 9mm.
I like it a lot.

That LCR is too big to roll up in your running socks. I have one of these holsters for my 380 and it's super comfy. It holds my wife's LCP as well. The one I linked is for the LCR. Other ankle holsters seemed to bite into my skin. As a reminder to anyone reading this - if you order from Amazon, please remember to use the smile.amazon.com link that TS posted a while back.

TrapperFrank · 01-08-2016, 11:28

My EDC is a Ruger LCP in .380, that being said, i carry it along with an extra magazine. It suits my needs and I am happy with it.

koz · 01-08-2016, 12:10

get the G43. It's a small good shooting pistol. The Shield isn't bad but the G43 is better shooting.

**Box** · 01-08-2016, 14:25

I can't carry in an ankle holster or a sock if I am running, carrying a gun when I am running does me no good.

-Even if I am running very slow (which in my current state is actually my only speed) I am usually breathing too hard to even SEE the sights much less hold them steady long enough to pull the trigger.
I can't stand the thought of being shot dead while holding a pistol because I am gasping for breath while trying to acquire a sight picture.

My defense posture if ever confronted while already running, is to continue running.
...and to try running in a serpentine pattern. Most people are incapable of taking well aimed shots while making rapid course corrections.
Serpentine everyone - SERPENTINE !!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1rmprF6e0RA

**Joker** · 01-08-2016, 15:22

Quote:

Originally Posted by Billy L-bach

I can't carry in an ankle holster or a sock if I am running, carrying a gun when I am running does me no good.

-Even if I am running very slow (which in my current state is actually my only speed) I am usually breathing too hard to even SEE the sights much less hold them steady long enough to pull the trigger.
I can't stand the thought of being shot dead while holding a pistol because I am gasping for breath while trying to acquire a sight picture.

My defense posture if ever confronted while already running, is to continue running.
...and to try running in a serpentine pattern. Most people are incapable of taking well aimed shots while making rapid course corrections.
Serpentine everyone - SERPENTINE !!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1rmprF6e0RA

Sawed-off shotgun.

zeke · 01-08-2016, 17:28

I have a Shield in .40 S&W that has been sent back two times and will be sent back again for Failure to Feed issues. I don't trust the gun.

I have an XDS in .45 that has had no issues. Side by side the guns seem to be almost exactly the same size. I haven't put as many rounds through the XDS but I have more faith in it than the Shield.

**The Reaper** · 01-08-2016, 17:42

Started with a Colt Commander, went to a Seecamp, a Para P-12 and then a P-10, a Kel-Tec P3AT, got a Ruger LC9 and carried it briefly (too many safeties, shitty trigger, clunky, bulky, very snappy), now experimenting with a Kahr CM9 and a Glock 19, depending on how well I can conceal it without an inappropriate amount of clothing.

I looked at the Smith Shield and Kel-Tec PF-9 as alternatives to the Kahr.

TR

DinDinA-2 · 01-08-2016, 18:22

I switch off carrying the M&P Shield 9 w/safety and a Ruger LC9s w/safety.

For the shield, I put in an Apex hard sear and striker block and the trigger is very nice now. 4 1/2 lbs or so. It was absolutely horrible before. Trigger a bit long on the first round, but nice short reset on follow up shots. For some reason, for me, I really have to focus to NOT shoot a bit left. Apex has good triggers to eliminate the take up...but who wants to spend over $100 on a $400 gun. Not quite as snappy as the LC9s.

The LC9s, again has a bit long trigger pull on the first round, subsequent shots nice short reset. Trigger pull is light, a bit lighter than I like. However I shoot it better than the shield.

The LC9s is very comfortable IWB, and small profile. The shield a bit less so.

The LC9s Pro comes with no mag disconnect, but no manual safety.

The LC9s comes with manual safety, but does have the mag disconnect. I took out the mag disconnect, because I wanted one with the manual safety.