Ant that nice..
I too like knobs, SDR systems are nice, but there is a lot of other things that can go bad real quick.
Too much to tell, but I have seen a SDR system, and what I've seen is all they did was move the smarts from the human to the radio.
Frequency selection will be done by a set of rules that are setup by other rules, but the question is always going back to who makes the rules, what country, and what level of priority does one get to over ride others in a SDR system? ( I know I am using SDR a lot, for that's what it is)
Systems are low power with the ability to select other spectrum to allow it to work, with out the op knowing it is taking place, but them again who's systems will it work on ?
This is a nice , but allowing an operator to kick in a "Special Channel" to talk to get that needed help when needed has always been my need. And I am not a needy guy, at times yes, like when the system fails do to EMI /RFI, and the rules are not set right for that radio to work. What then?
Like a lot of you, being in Spectrum management, EMI resolution, this dose not set well with this Ham.
A analog system has always worked, even when the Signal to noise ratio is bad for a digital systems to work. Now a digital works great when you need eyes on target to make sure it is the right target, you have it or you don't.
But like looking for that one tree in the forest, a analog system will allow me to hear that special tree, even when the trees have a lot of noise..
A lot out of the box, but that's how AL C's it..
BT AR