Quote:
Originally Posted by mojaveman
The Second Ammendment should be jettisoned?
Mr. Sweeny there is going to make himself a lot of enemies.
|
Hamilton, among others, fought a hard battle between Articles and a ratified (i.e., "sold to the buyers") Constitution. He was leery of a Bill of Rights in the first place for 2 reasons:
- the very "listing" of a right on a list potentially made it vulnerable to "reasonable regulation" (in whose eyes?) and the subsequent screwing with it from its intent, OR,
- the existence of something on a list opened the door to its continual expansion to the point where anything anyone wanted to do became "my right."
His view was that the very small list of stuff the Guv is allowed to do was already in the Constitution. "If it ain't there, hands off." Example: No reason to list rights of the press; Big G doesn't have the power to regulate them anyway - should be non-issue. Cowards let the G grow too big a very long time ago. Ol' Alexander looks pretty prescient lookin' back... he just might've been on to something.
Nowadays if someone has to eat their veggies or do their homework, someone's getting their rights violated. Criminy.
I imagine a similar process were this farce to be carried through and, given the current weak-kneed constitution of many Americans, may the best spin-doctor win.