Quote:
Originally posted by NousDefionsDoc
Where should the line be drawn? Flying a flag on foreign soil is a policy decision - not a matter to be taken lightly and definitely not one to be taken by your 19 year-old truck driver. It is not an individual decision, it is a matter of grave importance on the world stage.
As for the objectives of the GWOT in your list - identify the enemy.
Does flying the flag contribute in any way to numbers 2,3 and 4 - or would it be more detrimental, especially if left up to individuals and not tightly controlled?
|
Obviously I realize 19 year old truck drivers are not the ones that determine foreign policiy, however, I belive we were speaking about the ability of US Servicemembers to display the colors outside of their living quarters, not parade them around. Do you really belive that US units are not displaying the colors, national and unit on major installations?
As for items 2-4 on my list of objectives, I do not personally see how our National Colors is detrimental to the outcome of their outcome.
Personal opinion here, NDD.......based on 4 tours in this particular theater over the past 12 years, and debreifing every detachment that returns in preparation for my 5th tour over there very soon.
First, I belive If we are ruthless in our pursuit of the terrorists that are operating there and we act as world leaders I belive taht the majority of the world will see that they benifit from this strong presence and allie with us.
I believe that some idiots have already commited actions that have hurt us in this area, and we have to do everything we can to correct that error. That correction in no way includes showing weakness.
Right now Al Sadar has treated us with the same disrespect that Saddam did for years, and we are reacting with proportion in the same way the former administration did. We will not send troops in to holy sites, or buildings despite the terrorist insurgents using those sites and buildings as platforms and staging areas (sound like another conflict?). If Islam is being used as a basis for war, then the only way to combat it is to place no boundary to the strenght we will display. The terrorists will understand nothing else.
Again, personal opinion overcomes me here..........I belive that catering to a few of the locals here goes deeper than displaying a flag otuside of ones quarters. I belive the common Iraqi probably has no ill intentions to US Forces.........but the common Iraqi is quickly being recruited to the likes of Al Sadar, for reasons we havent yet been able to compete with.....
sorry, I'm a gunfighter, not a politician
mp