KBR Loses $24.1 Million Bonus Over Green Beret’s Death in Iraq

[Richard]

Too bad some of the $$ couldn't go to the Maseth family.

And so it goes...

Richard's $.02

KBR Loses $24.1 Million Bonus Over Green Beret’s Death in Iraq
Businessweek, 9 June 2010

KBR Inc., the largest contractor in Iraq, lost all of its potential bonus -- $24.1 million -- for the first four months of 2008 because it was found partly to blame for the accidental electrocution of a Green Beret.

This is the first time KBR lost its entire performance fee since the company won the contract in 2001 to support U.S. troops, Army Contracting Command spokesman Daniel Carlson said.

Houston-based KBR has received orders from this contract totaling $35.7 billion to date. Its profit comes from a base fee of 1 percent and periodic bonuses based on criteria such as quality of work and its control over cost and schedule.

Staff Sergeant Ryan Maseth of the 5th Special Forces Group was electrocuted while showering on Jan. 2, 2008, in part because the shower’s electrical pump wasn’t properly grounded when installed less than two years before, the Pentagon inspector general reported on July 27, 2009.

The report criticized the Army’s oversight of Maseth’s compound, saying his death “was the catastrophic result of the failure of multiple systems exposing U.S. personnel to unnecessary risk.”

Army commanders, the Army contracting command and KBR were all “responsible for the use and physical condition” of the compound, the report said.

“KBR did not ground equipment during installation or report improperly grounded equipment identified during routine maintenance” at the facility starting in February 2006, thereby “perpetuating electrical hazards,” the report found.

Accidental Death

The death was ruled accidental and KBR wasn’t found criminally negligent. Maseth’s mother, Cheryl A. Harris, in March 2008 filed a wrongful death suit against KBR. A federal judge last year denied a KBR dismissal motion. The case is pending in the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia.

The Army’s decision to deny KBR’s bonus followed a Jan. 7 report from its audit agency, which conducted its own investigation as well as reviewing the Pentagon inspector general’s report and the findings of an Army Criminal Investigation Command probe.

The $24.1 million wasn’t rolled into the subsequent award- fee period so KBR can’t earn it back, Carlson said in an e-mail.

KBR spokeswoman Gabriela Segura said the company was notified Feb. 19 that the fee wouldn’t be paid but hasn’t seen the Army audit “so it would be inappropriate to comment” at this time.

“We requested access to all information used so that we are better able to understand” the decision and “to determine whether there are additional actions that we might take,” she said.

KBR’s performance improved enough in the subsequent bonus periods from May 2008 through August 2009 for the Army to pay it $39.1 million of the $99.7 million available, or about 40 percent, according to the contracting command.

The Army announced May 6 that KBR received a new order worth as much as $568 million to continue to provide services in Iraq such as housing, meals, laundry, showers, water purification and bathroom cleaning.

http://www.businessweek.com/news/201...h-in-iraq.html

[Irish_Army01]

A question if I may.. Why can't a CSS unit do the work that KBR do?

[Maytime]

Originally Posted by Irish_Army01

A question if I may.. Why can't a CSS unit do the work that KBR do?

For a fraction of the cost I might add...

[37F]

I am currently on VBC..right now waiting on KBR to move a vehicle (which belongs to them) and we cant touch it even though we have a vehicle right here. These guys are taking all that money and are just sitting on their thumbs....

[The Reaper]

Originally Posted by Irish_Army01

A question if I may.. Why can't a CSS unit do the work that KBR do?

How big an Army do you want to pay for?

We have run the active, Guard, and reserve forces that we have into the ground.

How many do you want to get rid of when peace returns, and how do you select them?

TR

[Guy]

Originally Posted by The Reaper

How big an Army do you want to pay for?

We have run the active, Guard, and reserve forces that we have into the ground.

How many do you want to get rid of when peace returns, and how do you select them?

TR

It would cost the USG more $$$ in the long term also.

Stay safe.

[LarryW]

This was unsat. It's good the award fee was withdrawn or suspended, but $24M isn't a big deal when you're talking about billions in theater work. Award fees too often are more a matter of politics than they are an assessment of the quality of the work being performed. Too often you have PMs lobbying their resume to private companies they hope to work for once they pull the plug. IMO, this tragedy represents the piss poor QA being practiced in a lot of locations, from both public and private organizations; the lack of regulators or regulatory policies effectively doing what they're paid to do. In construction how hard is it to check a ground wire before putting a newly built shower in commission? Agree with Richard that the $$ should have gone to the Maseth family, followed by a thorough review by a team of pissed-off SF soldiers of all the award fees previously given to KBR.