I have a Trijicon Reflex and I love it.
To each his own I guess. My next sight purchase will be an eo-tech though.
I like the fact that the reflex is always "on", and never needs batteries.
I have the 6.5 MOA dot model. I zeroed it at 50m instead of 25m and it does great out to 300m.
The thing is fast as hell (and accurate) for CQB, IMHO.
A lot of folks are saying how the trijicon reflex is outdated.....I remember in the early 90's at 2nd Batt we had Armson OEG's and Aimpoints.....now everyone has aimpoints, and I don't see too much difference between the new M68 and the old aimpoints.
Like Reaper said, everyone is different, and some things work for some that don't work for others.
I wish I had the money for a 4x32 Acog....
I really think the EO Tech is the way to go, but I wouldn't knock a Trijicon reflex.......or even an aimpoint.
IMHO, the EO Tech or the reflex is better then iron sights for CQB.
My problem with the aimpoint is that it seems sometimes precious time is wasted trying to "find" the dot in relation to the target.
My 2 pesos.