Quote:
Originally Posted by bblhead672
|
The chart/study is slightly flawed. Checking analyses done for the Govt. was my "bread and butter" before 9/11 when regional EOC's were dumped in my lap.
I'll offer the analysis I did for my nephew (typical Kalifornian).
5 basketball players, earning $1,000,000 each are paying taxes on 5 Mil.
Along comes Pedro, displacing one. (as long as there are those seeking jobs, an American is displaced by each illegal).
We now have 5 players paying taxes on $5 Mil, just like before. There is no contribution on the plus side.
However, 4 of the 5 original players now have the burden of paying into social programs to support the displaced American. That displaced American has certainly not profited from the fact that Pedro is paying taxes. The results also go into the negative column.
When my division was in the business of analyzing studies going forward to D.C., we found 80% or more were flawed. (Folks at Rand still grit their teeth when they hear my name. )
When it comes to studies such as the above, I imagine the flaw rate is even higher