Professional Soldiers ® - View Single Post - SF History "What-If"

CommoGeek · 06-07-2004, 06:26

To provoke some discussion of SF history, I thought I'd get (with a nod toward RL) a stick this morning.

Knowing that some members of this board lived it, and the rest of us have studied it, is there an incident in the last 40 years that IF IT FAILED woud mean the end of SF, or maybe a greatly reduced role and/ or capacity?

If White Star, MACV-SOG, the "A" camps, Son Tay, Desert One, etc. fails (huge loss of life, little results, etc.), how different is modern SF?

What can you talk about that you would change about SF, excluding Son Tay and Desert One? For example, some have heartburn over SF having a branch, others may want the Reserve Groups to return, perhaps involvement in El Sal (the limit of 55 pax)....

What would you like to see reversed?

06-07-2004, 06:26	#1
CommoGeek Guerrilla Join Date: Jan 2004 Location: OCONUS Posts: 415	SF History "What-If" To provoke some discussion of SF history, I thought I'd get (with a nod toward RL) a stick this morning. Knowing that some members of this board lived it, and the rest of us have studied it, is there an incident in the last 40 years that IF IT FAILED woud mean the end of SF, or maybe a greatly reduced role and/ or capacity? If White Star, MACV-SOG, the "A" camps, Son Tay, Desert One, etc. fails (huge loss of life, little results, etc.), how different is modern SF? What can you talk about that you would change about SF, excluding Son Tay and Desert One? For example, some have heartburn over SF having a branch, others may want the Reserve Groups to return, perhaps involvement in El Sal (the limit of 55 pax).... What would you like to see reversed?
CommoGeek is offline