Why the Cowboy Code is Not Frivolous
 

http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2011/...us/?test=faces

A man’s got to have a code, a creed to live by, no matter his job." -- John Wayne

The other day the Montana State Senate passed SB 216 sponsored by rancher and Senate President Jim Peterson. The bill is simple and direct and it doesn’t cost the taxpayers a dime. SB 216 would adopt The Code of the West from the book "Cowboy Ethics" and make it the official Montana Code.

"Cowboy Ethics" was written by James Owen, an investment professional who after Enron and the other Wall Street scandals of a few years ago, decided it was time to take a good look at what we had become as a society and individuals. Like me he has a great deal of respect and admiration for the iconic American cowboy and the cowboy way of life.

He came up with his "Code of the West" which states some simple common sense principles that not just cowboys but all of us should try to live by.

The code includes admonitions such as "Live each day with courage," "Be tough, but fair," "Ride for the brand," and "Know where to draw the line."

About Social Security Benefits and Wage Garnishment Montana Governor Schweitzer has said he will veto any frivolous legislation. I guess he consider ethics "frivolous." He wants the legislature to focus on important things like jobs and a budget shortfall. He’s right that those things are extremely important. But the ethics and values deficit in this country is just as important as the fiscal and financial deficits.-- If life is just about dollars and cents then we are in bigger trouble than I thought.

Somewhere along the line we forgot these basic values and replaced them with a self-centered "grab all you can and forget the consequences" attitude and situational ethics.

Children cheat on tests and think it is not only okay but is a path to success.

In 2002 a study by Rutgers University found that cheating was rampant and in many cases accepted behavior among students. The director of the study said "I think kids today are looking to adults and society for a moral compass and when they see the behavior occurring there, they don't understand why they should be held to a higher standard."

If that is how our young people see the world Lord help us.

One student said,” I actually think cheating is good. A person who has an entirely honest life can't succeed these days."

Another student in the survey said, "What's important is getting ahead. The better grades you have, the better school you get into, the better you're going to do in life. And if you learn to cut corners to do that, you're going to be saving yourself time and energy. In the real world, that's what's going to be going on. The better you do, that's what shows. It's not how moral you were in getting there."

She was 17 at the time and by my ciphering she would be around 26 now. With an attitude like that she should run for Congress.

And I can’t imagine things have improved since 2002 and my guess is that they have gotten worse.

Some politicians cheat on their wives. If a man will cheat on his wife what do you think he will do to the folks that elected him?

Bad behavior in public life will more likely land you a book deal, a reality TV show or a spot on Oprah than the consternation of society. You want proof?

Disgraced former New York Governor Eliot Spitzer romped with hookers and he now has a television show on CNN.

By the way hookers are now called "escorts" and they have become a part of mainstream popular culture thanks to Spitzer and actor Charlie Sheen.

And while the collapse of the housing market has many causes one big one was that some unscrupulous lenders approved loans although they knew the borrowers could not afford them. By the way the borrowers also knew they couldn’t afford them as well and now some of them just walk away from their obligations.

Now that's a great example for the kids, isn't it?

Some folks might say I’m “naïve” or “old fashioned” or that “times have changed and I need to get with it” whatever “it” is.

Maybe so.

But when a nation forgets the values that made the country strong and discards its ethical compass as “outdated” that nation could be at its end.

And if not the end you sure as Hell can see it from here.

Cowboy Rules
 

Having grown up...or at least gotten older in Texas, we used to have the "Cowboy Rules" listed all over the place.
I have been using this one, "Good judgement comes from experience, and alot of that comes from bad judgement," for most of my life...to various degrees of success.

This brings up an interesting question about us civilians. Do you QPs think that it is appropriate for civilians to adopt creeds like the SF Creed or the Ranger Creed and apply them to their own personal lives?

Nice article. The part about student cheating drew my attention.

Some years ago, I was going through some assignments - simple ones that involved a few calculations on a spreadsheet. As background, I included instructions on the WWW. During class, I went through the entire procedure - everything, with no gaps - on how to create the spreadsheet. If any student (out of 160!) didn't understand, we went over it again.

So...no real reason to cheat, right?

But I got in one that looked absolutely splendid! It was almost a work of art as spreadsheets go. Except - even though the answers were right, the formulas were utterly wrong. Then I spotted a second assignment that looked just like it. So I required the students to provide the electronic files, which they did.

OK, at that point I found out that they had used Word instead of Excel. And the two students had files that were exact duplicates - and were created within 1 second of each other. Cheating, right?

I followed the book to the letter. Got the forms, filled them out, had the students sign them. The students would have gotten a zero on the assignment - but no other sanctions.

And what did my boss do? He refused to sign them. It was "too much trouble". Since then, I have noticed that even cheating on tests is not pursued. Officially, academic dishonesty is deplored and punished. Practically speaking - it is ignored.

This leads to many bad things. One can imagine what happens when a doctor, engineer, or other professional gets used to such behavior. I think we're reaping part of the consequences now.

Could we as civilians adopt a robust moral or ethical code? Sure - as long as we limit it to defining our own behavior. But those who try to impose it on any part of the greater society will pay a price.

As a friend says, "Once you lose your integrity, the rest is easy." Please forgive me for concluding that his cynical comment comes close to the truth.

This Country settled into a trial lawyer's ideal with regard to integrity about the time of the Lewinsky brouhaha.

Had a math teacher in Junior High who gave a mutiple choice test to first period and, oddly enough, the answers ran "a,b,c,d, repeat". News of this spread like wild-fire through the rest of the his classes.

Guess what.
Three Texans ridin' in a pick-up. Which ones the REAL Cowboy?

The one in the middle.
Don't have to drive, Don't have to mess with the gate.

Back in the 80's, we went to Biggs AAF to train on the DMVS (Desert Mobility Vehicle System. We'd drive though the country side a few hundred miles along the border. We were told the only rule we had better never violate was "Leave the gate the way you found it".

That, and don't take the government van to Juarez.

TR

Y'all have an issue you need to deal with if that is the case there.

FWIW - kids make poor decisions but still need to be held accountable for them while having the opportunity to demonstrate a willingness to own up to and correct those behaviors. We found an enforcable 'Three Strike' policy for cheating/academic dishonesty (plagiarism) worked well for us.

Strike One

• An automatic '0' on the assignment/exam
• Original assignment w/documentation/memos kept in the student's permanent academic file
• Counseling on the effects of the '0' and the violation of the policy regarding cheating/academic honesty
• Parent meeting to discuss the issue and information on its consequences
• Note: a '0' sometimes meant the student failed the course for the semester; I had seniors who cheated on a final exam or plagiarized a final term paper in a core course and had to re-do the course in summer school before receiving their diplomas

Strike Two

• Automatic failure of the course
• Counseling and parent meeting
• Academic probation

Strike Three

• Dismissal

There were several occasions when we 'strongly' suspected a student had cheated but could not prove it - however, when confronted with such an issue, we had the student retake the exam or redo the assignment while being monitored by faculty as 'proof' of 'their' integrity and then averaged the two grades for a final academic grade.

After enforcing and holding to our polciy (as outlined in the Students and Parents Handbook) and having several students fail courses, fail to graduate with their class due to the need to retake a course in summer school, and dismissing a student for a 'Strike Three', the word was out to the community and the issue was seldom a problem for us.

Those aren't 'real' Texans - real Texans have cattle guards so nobody has to mess with any damn gates. ;)

And so it goes...

Richard :munchin

True - and folks who have been there since inception 30+ years ago agree. However, the realities of the demographics, retention rates and politics mean that nothing is done.

That's the problem with codes of ethics, IMO. One starts off with a little compromise, a small white lie, a bending of the rules and it is so very easy. One follows the path, one easy step at a time. Ultimately, one has an issue. It takes someone with a very strong moral compass to fight such trends and environments. Perhaps that's one reason I admire many here - they seem to have that strength.

Cattle guards only work some of the time. A shut gate works all the time...until your fenceline gets a break.

As for your three strike rule...I think it's great...but here's an issue we have in our county (my wife's been teaching for 21 years). Her principle refuses to let any teacher give their student a zero. Reason? It's so hard to overcome a zero on a report card. Instead give them a 60. It's still a failing grade but then the little johnnies and joannies can recover. Sadly though they don't learn the lesson that their actions (or inactions) have consequences.

Yeah, that's the Brokeback Mountain Cowboy Code

We ascribed to a similar policy in that we didn't give below a 50 for an assignment - if the student got a 50, they knew that the number represented the teacher's effort and not the student's - the teacher had done their half of giving the student the opportunity to achieve a 100 but the student did not.

HOWEVER - cheating or plagiarizing on an exam/assignment automatically gave you a '0'.

Richard :munchin

What have you done about this issue since then?

It's a great idea!!!
 

If you were to write a prayer - Ranger or SF type creed, what would it say, and would you follow it, live by it?

Could you creatively blend the principles and the "Pledge of Allegiance" and the 6 last commandments of service, love and honoring your neighbor, (I've intentionally removed the first 4, as to not hurt anyone's sensitivities), but include them as you see fit.

Could you place honor and fighting injustices or wrong when seen? To always place the needs of others before your own, to protect small children, the aged, women or the sick? (I excluded young men, and men, in this line of thinking because if you are a man, then you should be able to protect yourself, protect one anothers, and protect the former).


---------------- now a plug for another -----------


"Cowboy Ethics", by James Owens was required reading in my last company.

I have forwarded many copies of Owens' book to others with warm replies, and endless (thank you's).

I got my first copy of "Cowboy Ethics", from Jack Dale who has also written a book entitled, "The Code". Personally, I think it should be required reading of all men, boys, and women who have to live with us. I think it should also be read by all SF candidates, their brothers and fathers, and the women, (wives, sisters, girl friends, etc.), who have to live with them, in short, I think everyone should read 'The Code".

I only mention this, because the question was asked, should civilian types adopt the SF or Ranger creed to live by? The answer is Yes. Go write a creed, some civilians live by such convictions, they even write books about it.

Wet Dog

Me personally? I obey orders without question. Or even much thought.

Others who have been around 30+ years and have tenure? They complain about the decline in standards over coffee, then obey orders without question.

I didn't say I was proud of myself.