Professional Soldiers ®

Professional Soldiers ® (http://www.professionalsoldiers.com/forums/index.php)
-   The Soapbox (http://www.professionalsoldiers.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=93)
-   -   General Mattis Departure - Symptomatic or Systemic (http://www.professionalsoldiers.com/forums/showthread.php?t=54051)

WarriorDiplomat 12-29-2018 22:30

Quote:

Originally Posted by Agoge2 (Post 648636)
To me, the saddest part of that is that the sheep have allowed themselves to be led by fear. They are scared of everything and the political wolves, MSM, etc., all know and exploit it to the fullest. Pathetic really!

Agreed

That is why I usually stop take a deep breath and calmly start looking at the situation...if it even effects me in any way...keeping a healthy skepticism is important to avoid being made a fool of and enough life experience to recognize when something sounds foolish and enough intellectual curiosity coupled with common sense to ignore unrealistic crap and investigate plausible stuff that concerns me.

JGC2 12-30-2018 02:24

I was always confused by QPs who adored Mattis after the well known story of him leaving ODA 574 out to dry when he was the Commander at Camp Rhino. He did nothing remarkable or identifiably friendly to SF as CENTCOM Commander, and he rolled over on women in SOF and trannies as SECDEF. The myth of him as some sort of warfighter ignores that he was a staff officer for all of GWOT and beyond. I say good riddance.

Old Dog New Trick 12-30-2018 10:35

If Stanley McChrystal left any doubt in anyone’s mind as to his allegiance to the military over his views on politics and gun control this should help clear that up.

https://apple.news/AvekQCcxVT3eGXuGO2rd9GA

President Trump immoral, doesn't tell the truth: Retired Army Gen. Stanley McChrystal

What a tool he became for those next couple of stars if not a liar his whole career.

Box 12-30-2018 12:02

Quote:

Originally Posted by Old Dog New Trick (Post 648652)
If Stanley McChrystal left any doubt...
...over his views on politics https://apple.news/AvekQCcxVT3eGXuGO2rd9GA.

"If we want to be governed by someone we wouldn't do a business deal with because their -- their background is so shady, if we're willing to do that, then that's in conflict with who I think we are. And so I think it's necessary at those times to take a stand."


...you know - the way we trusted folks like Kennedy, LBJ, Nixon, Carter, Regan, Bush, Clinton, or even the Choom-Gang POTUS


Nothing beats a lesson on honor and integrity like getting that lesson from a guy that lost his job for shit talking his commander in chief.
Now if only we could get some hip pocket training on how to identify sanctimonious behavior by people of power - we'd be ready for anything.

Old Dog New Trick 12-30-2018 12:55

He must’ve had some real shattering mirror moments with Hamid Karsai...how many years of bad luck after breaking a mirror?

Badger52 12-30-2018 14:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by Box (Post 648655)
"[I]Now if only we could get some hip pocket training on how to identify sanctimonious behavior by people of power - we'd be ready for anything.

Of all the things the Human Genome Project couldn't tell us...

"You do not have to remind me that man is not equal to his rhetoric. "
- Dante, in The Russia House

tonyz 12-30-2018 16:48

Quote:

Originally Posted by Old Dog New Trick (Post 648652)
If Stanley McChrystal left any doubt in anyone’s mind as to his allegiance to the military over his views on politics and gun control this should help clear that up.

https://apple.news/AvekQCcxVT3eGXuGO2rd9GA

President Trump immoral, doesn't tell the truth: Retired Army Gen. Stanley McChrystal

What a tool he became for those next couple of stars if not a liar his whole career.

That interview was simply a hit piece by two never Trumpers. And, if they sell books it’s all gravy.

Please General..the other choice was Hillary “Benghazi” Klinton...look into that “integrity” mirror and let me know what you see.

The political elite are scared shitless of Trump pulling back the curtain on the shit show that is DC.

TrapperFrank 12-30-2018 17:11

POTUS Trump is a Grade A son of a bitch. That said, sometimes it takes a Grade A son of a bitch to accomplish the task at hand. Full disclosure, I did not vote for POTUS Trump. I voted for the guy from New Mexico, Gary what's his name. After 8 years of beta male leadership by Dear Leader O'Bumbles it is refreshing to watch a Grade A son of a bitch at work. He gets stuff done.

Ret10Echo 12-30-2018 21:39

Trump is not part of the "system". That scares the collective because he doesn't give a shit about breaking things. He's the modem day version of the fire ship drifting into the political safehaven of Washington DC.

By the way, I hate all political parties of which there is really only one.... so I don't have a horse in this race. Only the American people and the Constitution.

WarriorDiplomat 12-30-2018 22:09

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ret10Echo (Post 648664)
Trump is not part of the "system". That scares the collective because he doesn't give a shit about breaking things. He's the modem day version of the fire ship drifting into the political safehaven of Washington DC.

By the way, I hate all political parties of which there is really only one.... so I don't have a horse in this race. Only the American people and the Constitution.

As it should be...isn't it a shame that the networks the supports the two main parties is so deeply entrenched that without the support of one or the other their is almost no way for someone to win without the worker bees in every city already in place free of charge.?

tonyz 12-31-2018 09:24

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ret10Echo (Post 648664)
Trump is not part of the "system". That scares the collective because he doesn't give a shit about breaking things. He's the modem day version of the fire ship drifting into the political safehaven of Washington DC.

By the way, I hate all political parties of which there is really only one.... so I don't have a horse in this race. Only the American people and the Constitution.

Well said. Concur completely.

Flagg 12-31-2018 18:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by TrapperFrank (Post 648660)
POTUS Trump is a Grade A son of a bitch. That said, sometimes it takes a Grade A son of a bitch to accomplish the task at hand. Full disclosure, I did not vote for POTUS Trump. I voted for the guy from New Mexico, Gary what's his name. After 8 years of beta male leadership by Dear Leader O'Bumbles it is refreshing to watch a Grade A son of a bitch at work. He gets stuff done.

I’m of a very similar mind.

I don’t like the guy at all.

Recently, I read a book called “A Covert Action: Reagan, the CIA, and the Cold War struggle for Poland”.

A truly excellent book, telling a fantastic true story.

It also gives another great profile on President Ronald Reagan’s oversimplistic but highly effective good/evil viewpoint and ideological war against communism.

But I think the world has changed and the US is once again less politically civil.

I don’t think a gentleman like President Reagan would survive in an era of shock & awe social media politics.

President Trump is a brash, disruptive, unapologetic bully compared to President Reagan.

But if you’re in an existential fight, do you want a gentleman or a mongrel?

Badger52 12-31-2018 18:08

Quote:

Originally Posted by Flagg (Post 648672)
But if you’re in an existential fight, do you want a gentleman or a mongrel?

Precisely. The other side loves it, drooling, when those they seek to destroy get all "civlized" on 'em.

Me? I'll take some more CAS please - pile 'em up.

GratefulCitizen 12-31-2018 18:17

Suspect that the general knows his stuff, and advocated for the best interests of the mission associated with his appointment.
Also suspect that the POTUS knows and has considered this.

However, the POTUS has a larger scale mission, and the general's mission has to fit within a larger set of priorities.
Mattis had views consistent with his SECDEF mission, and Trump made decisions consistent with his POTUS mission.

Trump is accountable to the people.
Time will tell which calls were the right ones.

Badger52 12-31-2018 19:23

Quote:

Originally Posted by Flagg (Post 648672)
Recently, I read a book called “A Covert Action: Reagan, the CIA, and the Cold War struggle for Poland”.

A truly excellent book, telling a fantastic true story.

It also gives another great profile on President Ronald Reagan’s oversimplistic but highly effective good/evil viewpoint and ideological war against communism.

Get it here. (and yeah, shamelessly linked to smile.amazon, so set yours up to support GBF, or some other worthy outfit you think Bezos should kick in some bucks for).

Looking forward to it; my small town library - with a Rottweiler who handles inter-library loan searches - has it on the way. Winter ist lang, Kamerad.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 16:40.


Copyright 2004-2022 by Professional Soldiers ®