Quote:
Originally Posted by goon175
(Post 419235)
First and foremost, they should be putting out those soldiers who cannot pass a PT test, or are overweight. I would say after we get those types out, then move on to the guys who have had run-ins with the law.
|
Alternate viewpoint, although I've heard from many who cite the PT test as an important factor, and I respect that viewpoint. I see great logic in having different PT tests to qualify for the different MOS's. I doubt that a good mess sergeant will ever need to ruck 100 pounds or toss a grenade with accuracy. And, a tough PT test for combat arms, perhaps an even tougher one for SpecOps sounds reasonable, screening out those who yell about opportunity instead of the needs of the unit.
But I also wonder if his brothers are trying to help him make the grade.
I'm one who experienced a couple of good SF Colonels, one who brought me into the 1st Group to rebuild and learn, because he knew how much I wanted that flash and a second one who told me I could work out any time during the day that I could spare me from my duties.
Heck. I had a B-team leader who taught me to dive and harrassed me appropriately under water. He was even trying to figure out how to get me out of an aircraft HALO style without getting his butt badly burned, when we were booted off the island.
And there was the S-3 who tossed down the gauntlet for 3 on 3 volleyball during lunch, to help rebuild my endurance as well as muscle. That was Dick Meadows, THE Dick Meadows. His greatness wasn't limited to his military skills.
And, those last 3 paragraphs aren't directly on topic, but close enough I think. They have gone thru my mind often when I see questions from support troops who want to be a QP. If you're busting your butt, help comes to you from all over. Every QP I met seemed to go out of their way to make those who weren't feel like a full part of the team.
Never got the body back to what it was, but the "us" approach in the group was constant, and I never saw a hint of "not one of us". Turned what could have been the most bitter years of my life into memories I'll never give up. :)
Especially to the FOGs, I just needed to say that.:)