Quote:
Originally Posted by Razor
Have you read "Lt Ramsey's War", by Edwin Price Ramsey?
|
Yup! I reckon it's a good one...above average for the topic.
Available on Kindle and good bang for the buck.
What I've come to learn from reading the range of content regarding US guerilla operations in the Philippines is that I received more value reading as much across the board as I possibly can, to the point of drowning in it.
My reason for this is to gain a more comprehensive perspective from what appears to be a bit of political infighting and conflicting narratives.
The best example I can find on that is using the book I'm currently reading:
They Fought Alone by John Keats. It's like a biographical novel of Wendell Fertig's perspective on the guerilla war waged in the PI in WWII.
But I've found this piece by Clyde Childress who fought alongside Fertig under his command that rebuts some substantial slices of the book:
https://fireinthejungle.files.wordpr...l_fertig_s.pdf
In no way am I trying to disparage what was done by anyone who improvised, adapted, and overcame during those years in the bush...especially considering the lack of specific training and resources available.
So I would think a whole lot of mistakes would have been made in trial and error as well as identifying and highlighting some of the human characteristics/qualities that SF compels and avoids.
I reckon the Jedburghs and OGs are fantastic to read about from the perspective of formal early SF training and doctrine development and execution.
But I think the subtle (and sometimes conflicting) bits and pieces of the Philippine on the job training UW marathon campaign has a lot of really valuable and timeless lessons.
I'm just an avid fan of the Philippine campaign and early SF/UW development, so I wouldn't call myself a UW SME by any means...which means take it with a grain of salt.
But with the recent conflicting narratives I've read about the OJT UW campaign in Philippines, I wonder if any part of it is analogous to the perception of conflicting narratives and viewpoints within the SF community earlier in the current conflicts?
In short...read it, and then read as much as you can about the topic from other perspectives.
Fortunately, there's a fair bit of inexpensive content out there and a good chunk of it on Kindle/PDF.
EDIT: Whoops! Didn't see you were a QP...you've probably read/done/taught it all.