PDA

View Full Version : Sailor acquitted in USS Bonhomme Richard fire


mojaveman
09-30-2022, 18:02
The Navy's USS Bonhomme Richard was destroyed in a fire while docked in San Diego to undergo millions of dollars in maintenance.

I kind of thought the guy may have been a scapegoat. Now some officers up the chain of command might start feeling some heat. It's still baffling how a large ship made entirely of steel could be destroyed in a fire.

https://www.foxnews.com/us/naval-sailor-acquitted-arson-fire-destroyed-uss-bonhomme-richard-san-diego

JJ_BPK
10-01-2022, 06:46
It's still baffling how a large ship made entirely of steel could be destroyed in a fire.




There were similar questions as to the fall of the twin towers.

The fire softened and melted large sections. From some of the pictures, I think other soft meltable metals were used to save weight.


In one of the articles, the defense, in closing, shaded the prosecution by implying they ignored the "real" evidence. I wonder if there will be a second trial. :munchin

Golf1echo
10-01-2022, 08:38
Structure is an interesting study. Fire in a wood structure is burning the gas within the wood , basically charring the wood, failure is more predictable, if you will.

In a steel structure fire creates a sudden failure within the bonds of the metal, the structure generally under greater stress fails suddenly.

https://internationaltimber.com/resources/how-does-timber-handle-fire-compared-to-steel-and-concrete/

Airbornelawyer
10-01-2022, 10:45
I kind of thought the guy may have been a scapegoat.

Now, the Navy would never do something like that, ... cough, Iowa.

Badger52
10-01-2022, 15:39
Now, the Navy would never do something like that, ... cough, Iowa.Precisely.

MR2
10-04-2022, 09:55
Now, the Navy would never do something like that, ... cough, Iowa.

Pearl Harbor, USS Indianapolis, USS Pueblo, gawd the list is endless...