Log in

View Full Version : Iran vs ISIS


frostfire
06-07-2017, 12:51
Suicide attacks at the Parliament and Khomeini Tomb. 12 killed so far.

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-40184641

well the plot sure thickens.
Sure, the enemy of my enemy is my friend, but what a headache. Perhaps a chance to ally with Iran....but the current administration already made their pick.

If nothing else, the fact that the attackers were dressed as women and eluded security should show the tactical disadvantage of having folks in burqa as everyday garment. France got it right.

Team Sergeant
06-07-2017, 13:03
Suicide attacks at the Parliament and Khomeini Tomb. 12 killed so far.

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-40184641

well the plot sure thickens.
Sure, the enemy of my enemy is my friend, but what a headache. Perhaps a chance to ally with Iran....but the current administration already made their pick.

If nothing else, the fact that the attackers were dressed as women and eluded security should show the tactical disadvantage of having folks in burqa as everyday garment. France got it right.

Uh no, it doesn't, it moron shia Vs. idiot sunni. Has not changed in a few thousand years. I've said before unleash shia Iran to deal with sunni saudi's and they will crush isis.

Airbornelawyer
06-07-2017, 16:43
Based on my observations of Iranian actions in Iraq, Syria and Lebanon, I do not think Iran in particularly interested in crushing ISIS or al-Qaeda. They certainly view them as an enemy, but just one of many and after the Greater and Lesser Satans of the US and Israel. Rather, they seem to to prefer fighting these Sunni enemies to some extent, but not trying to remove the threat entirely, in order to make Arab Shi'ites dependent on Iran.

The US-led coalition had an opportunity to help build an Iraq-based Shi'a alternative to Khomeinist Iran's version of Shi'a Islam, but that opportunity has been pretty much lost. Not that the Iraqi Shi'as are particularly moderate by Western standards, but they were certainly better than the Iranian version and they welcomed our liberation from Saddam.

The Iranians and their proxies clearly recognized the threat, as seen by their assassinations of so many Iraqi Ayatollahs. Meanwhile, during the reconstruction, the US-led coalition probably bent over backwards far too much to be even-handed among all the Iraqi factions, rather than favoring those Kurds, Shi'a and Sunni groups who actually favored us. And, of course, every Shi'ite Arab knew that while the US might grow tired and just pack up and leave, Iran would always be next door, so even if they would have preferred a better relationship with the US to one with Iran, the geopolitical reality favored Iran. And then the Obama Administration made it clear that the US could not be relied on.

I still find it hard to understand why Obama, Kerry and so many US officials were so insistent on making an Iran deal their signature foreign policy accomplishment, but I suppose it is possible they thought it was a quid pro quo for Iranian cooperation against ISIS. If so, I suppose Iran is using us just like they are using the Iraqi and Lebanese Shi'ites and the Syrian Alawites.

frostfire
06-18-2017, 16:09
http://www.timesofisrael.com/iran-launches-missile-strike-into-syria-for-tehran-attacks/

well, that escalates.

How long before one lands on Riyadh, accidental or otherwise

Based on my observations of Iranian actions in Iraq, Syria and Lebanon, I do not think Iran in particularly interested in crushing ISIS or al-Qaeda. They certainly view them as an enemy, but just one of many and after the Greater and Lesser Satans of the US and Israel. Rather, they seem to to prefer fighting these Sunni enemies to some extent, but not trying to remove the threat entirely, in order to make Arab Shi'ites dependent on Iran.

so you'd surmise that the missile launch is posturing akin to ours after the chemical attack?

Team Sergeant
06-19-2017, 10:08
http://www.timesofisrael.com/iran-launches-missile-strike-into-syria-for-tehran-attacks/

well, that escalates.

How long before one lands on Riyadh, accidental or otherwise


so you'd surmise that the missile launch is posturing akin to ours after the chemical attack?

Who cares? :munchin