PDA

View Full Version : History Channel Nixes Conservative Producer's Show


Dusty
01-08-2011, 10:29
http://www.foxnews.com/entertainment/2011/01/07/history-channel-nixes-conservative-producers-kennedy-miniseries-complaints/?test=faces

PASADENA, Calif. -- The History Channel will not air a controversial miniseries it produced about the Kennedy family, saying the multimillion project that had become the network's most expensive on record did not fit the "History brand."

The eight-part series had already been completed, and starred Greg Kinnear and Katie Holmes as President John F. Kennedy and his wife, Jackie. But during its production, critics like former Kennedy administration aide Theodore Sorenson attacked the scripts as inaccurate. The role of producer Joel Surnow, a political conservative, also drew suspicion from fans of the Kennedy family.

"We have concluded this dramatic interpretation is not a fit for the History brand," the network said in a statement late Friday.

The decision was first reported Friday by the Hollywood Reporter.

History, in its statement, said the decision was made after viewing the series in its totality.

"We recognize historical fiction is an important medium for storytelling and commend all the hard work and passion that has gone into the making of the series, but ultimately deem this as the right programming decision for our network," History said in a statement.

Spokesman Michael Feeney said there would be no further comment.

Messages left with Surnow's agent and lawyer were not immediately returned on Friday.

History is owned by the A&E Television Networks, which itself is owned jointly by NBC Universal, the Walt Disney Co. and the Hearst Corp.

It's not clear who made the decision to pull the plug on "The Kennedys," given the joint ownership. A top Disney executive, Disney-ABC Media Networks co-chairwoman Anne Sweeney, is also on the board of directors for the Special Olympics, the organization started by the late Eunice Kennedy Shriver, President Kennedy's sister.

Liberal filmmaker Robert Greenwald was behind a petition drive to get the movie shelved. A website, stopkennedysmears.com, was set up with a short film that attacked the miniseries.

The decision was reminiscent of CBS' 2003 decision not to air a miniseries based on the life of President Ronald Reagan, which had also attracted political controversy prior to airing. The series later aired on the Showtime pay cable network.

Greenwald said more than 50,000 people had signed his petition.

"I'll never understand why the History channel let it get as far as it did -- they're intelligent people over there -- but we're pleased that they came to this decision," he said.

His YouTube film quoted Sorenson, a former adviser to Kennedy, calling a script he had seen of "The Kennedys" vindictive and malicious. Sorenson said scenes in the script that depicted him meeting with President Kennedy did not occur.

Greenwald said he had been slipped a copy of the script while the film was casting actors. His film included a "dramatization" of some of the scenes, including one where President Kennedy supposedly tells his brother Robert about why he needed to have sex with different women.

It's not clear whether that scene, or others that he depicted, ever made it into the final film.

Although History is not airing it, "The Kennedys" is expected to be seen elsewhere around the world. History does not control rights to the film outside of the United States and the company that does, Muse Entertainment, has sold rights to various other networks. It is scheduled to air March 6 in Canada, for example.

The film would have aired in this country during the 50th anniversary of the start of the Kennedy presidency.

The Reaper
01-08-2011, 10:55
Curious.

I thought the political leanings of the producers and directors was irrelevant.

I guess that is only true if they are libs.

TR

akv
01-08-2011, 12:42
His film included a "dramatization" of some of the scenes, including one where President Kennedy supposedly tells his brother Robert about why he needed to have sex with different women.

While conceding a liberal media bias, if folks at The History Channel took their mandate seriously, since no one but the two brothers could corroborate such a conversation, while perhaps dramatically interesting, if the series featured numerous such instances, wouldn't this fall outside the bounds of professionalism, or constitute drama better performed elsewhere. All history is biased, but isn't this channel's credibility linked to an earnest attempt to portray historical facts?

Dusty
01-08-2011, 12:49
While conceding a liberal media bias, if folks at The History Channel took their mandate seriously, since no one but the two brothers could corroborate such a conversation, while perhaps dramatically interesting, if the series featured numerous such instances, wouldn't this fall outside the bounds of professionalism, or constitute drama better performed elsewhere. All history is biased, but isn't this channel's credibility linked to an earnest attempt to portray historical facts?

Either:

1). You've never watched the History Channel.

0r

2). You're Barbra Streisand

akv
01-08-2011, 12:59
Dusty,

Thats a first, lol, though better Barbara Streisand, than Jane Fonda...

My question is does it always have to be a liberal conspiracy?

Sigaba
01-08-2011, 14:34
This story does not surprise me.

Back in 1992, Robert Dallek shared his experiences and thoughts on the first volume of his biography of Lydon B. Johnson with a handful of graduate students studying presidential politics at the LBJ School of Government.

By this time, Dallek had already established himself as a historian in the same liberal tradition as Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr. with his magisterial study of FDR's foreign policy.

Dallek spoke briefly about the interference he'd received from the JFK Presidential Library staff. Dallek intimated his frustration that the staff seemed to want to know what he was going to write about Kennedy before he'd even done his research at that facility.

Dusty
01-08-2011, 14:55
Dusty,

Thats a first, lol, though better Barbara Streisand, than Jane Fonda...

My question is does it always have to be a liberal conspiracy?


Naw. They don't have to conspire anymore; they're blatantly flagrant in their bias.

It's not just this example. What do you expect from something originating from Hearst?

ApacheIP
01-08-2011, 15:01
Funny that...isn't this is the network that gave us Ice Road Truckers, Stan Lee's Super Humans, and the dreadful Top Gear American version? :rolleyes:

Dusty
01-08-2011, 16:00
Funny that...isn't this is the network that gave us Ice Road Truckers, Stan Lee's Super Humans, and the dreadful Top Gear American version? :rolleyes:

Don't forget Ancient Aliens.

BoyScout
01-08-2011, 20:58
Don't forget Ancient Aliens.

And Monster Quest, Gangland, as well as conspiracy shows. I found myself watching less and less starting when they started to look more and more like Spike TV.

Dozer523
01-08-2011, 21:21
Dusty,
My question is does it always have to be a liberal conspiracy?

Around here? yeah.:D

Naw. They don't have to conspire anymore; they're blatantly flagrant in their bias.
It's not just this example. What do you expect from something originating from Hearst?

Oh, never mind. It's definately not a conspiracy. Maybe a genetic defect? (caused by wealth?)

trvlr
01-08-2011, 21:24
Don't forget Ancient Aliens.

One of the worst shows I've ever seen.

All punditry aside, I've never understood America's unbridled love for all things Kennedy. Especially Ted.

Dozer523
01-08-2011, 21:32
I've never understood America's unbridled love for all things Kennedy. Especially Ted. On a similiar line I've always wondered why my younger brother is invited home at Christmas. I guess it's a "he's the youngest" thing. My Mom belives the secret to a happy life is to "pick an age you like and stick with it." She explains my 'lil bro thus, "Dozer you picked 33, your brother picked 12."

"Happy families are all alike; every unhappy family is unhappy in its own way."
Leo Tolstoy, Anna Karenina,

Dusty
01-09-2011, 06:09
On a similiar line I've always wondered why my younger brother is invited home at Christmas. I guess it's a "he's the youngest" thing. My Mom belives the secret to a happy life is to "pick an age you like and stick with it." She explains my 'lil bro thus, "Dozer you picked 33, your brother picked 12."

"Happy families are all alike; every unhappy family is unhappy in its own way."
Leo Tolstoy, Anna Karenina,

:D LMAO

Dusty
01-09-2011, 06:13
One of the worst shows I've ever seen.

All punditry aside, I've never understood America's unbridled love for all things Kennedy. Especially Ted.

Bro, don't lump the whole Country in with the "unbridled love", if you don't mind.

greenberetTFS
01-09-2011, 06:26
Around here? yeah.:D



Oh, never mind. It's definately not a conspiracy. Maybe a genetic defect? (caused by wealth?)

Tim,

I see your back into your good form again......... :cool: That's the Dozer I missed.....;)

Big Teddy :munchin

greenberetTFS
01-09-2011, 06:34
One of the worst shows I've ever seen.

All punditry aside, I've never understood America's unbridled love for all things Kennedy. Especially Ted.

Screw Ted,But SF has a special place in our hearts for JFK,he did give us our Green Beret...;)

Big Teddy :munchin

Dusty
01-09-2011, 07:38
The History Channel and The Learning Channel used to be good channels with decent quality, scholarly shows, unfortunately, that is not what the general public likes to watch (this is a country where shows like American Idol and Queer Eye for the Straight Guy crush in the ratings).

So the History channel has since morphed into a shell of its former self with shows such as the ones listed before, The Learning Channel gave up that name to be called "TLC" and they have lots of reality shows and other such stuff now, the latest channel to go to crap was Court TV.

Court TV used to be a much more serious channel, but then they morphed it into "Tru TV" and turned it into a version of Spike TV with cop car chase shows and so forth. However, the ratings shot way up on it, as this is what the public likes.


Not in the least because of Brad "Macho Man" Meltzer and decoced.