View Full Version : Reporters Helping Insurgents

Roguish Lawyer
07-07-2004, 17:19
I suggest clicking the link so you can see the photos. This should trigger a good discussion.


Reporter gets inside look at insurgency
Attack videos put journalist at personal, professional risk
From Brent Sadler
Wednesday, July 7, 2004 Posted: 12:52 PM EDT (1652 GMT)

BAGHDAD, Iraq (CNN) -- Islamic insurgent groups in Iraq are taking an unexpected step to give an inside view of their terror attacks on Westerners by sharing video not only of the assaults, but also of the planning behind them.

"This video is straight from the mujahedeen," journalist Michael Ware said as he viewed the tape at a hotel in Baghdad. "This is the Blackwater killings. They talk about planning it. I can't believe this."

Ware, an Australian reporter working for TIME magazine, is walking a professional knife-edge, an unlikely go-between for anti-Western militants and the media.

"They've been filming this stuff from the beginning," Ware said as he watched what purports to be the attack that killed four employees of Blackwater Security Consulting in Fallujah in late March.

According to eyewitnesses at the time, a group of men, their faces covered by headscarves, split into two groups and threw hand grenades into the two vehicles that carried the contractors. As the vehicles were engulfed with flames, the assailants sprayed them with small arms fire, the witnesses said.

A mob then dragged the four civilians' mutilated bodies through the streets and hung two of them from a bridge over the Euphrates River as people cheered.

U.S. military officials who investigated the attack suspected it was planned because the normally busy city streets were empty and the shops closed at the time of the assault.

But they may not have known just how carefully the assault was planned.

On the insurgent video, a hooded man claiming to represent a group called the Islamic Army in Iraq shows how a satellite image was used to map out the attack route, circling the point of contact.

"This is clearly a military map of some sort," Ware said while watching the video. "That's an e-mail, and that's a Blackwater letterhead," he said. "It's got the names of the recipients, the date.'

Also shown on the videotape are the possessions of the dead contractors.

Frightening access to world of insurgents
Ware's life changed when he received a tape of a Pakistani hostage after more than a year of reporting on the insurgency.

"Since they gave me the hostage tape 10 days ago -- the first Westerner to get a hostage tape -- it's like that was them opening up," he said. "And in the 10 days that's followed, I've been getting access that's quite frightening. And in the last three days, I've received seven new tapes from different parts of the resistance -- Islamic guerillas, Iraqi nationalists and independents."

A fiery explosion rocks bystanders in this video shot by militants.
The tape contains what a group called Unity and Jihad, led by most-wanted terrorist Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, claims is a start-to-finish attack videotape.

"They have reached a level of organization and sophistication that we have not seen previously," Ware said. "They have become incredibly savvy."

What's said to be an al-Zarqawi camera captures the sequence of a suicide bomber bidding farewell to fellow insurgents and then boarding a tanker that is wired to 3.5 tons of explosives.

"Something in the last few months has got them filming the most intimate, graphic attacks -- like up-close and personal," Ware said. "It's like they are embedding combat camera units, who are there on the front line with them, knowing they are going to have propaganda value in time to come."

The other purpose for the videotapes, Ware said, is to terrorize Westerners.

"They're trying to tell the Western public: 'This is what your boys are dying for, this is what they are up against,' " he said. "They are letting us know that, 'We can kill your boys, and we are not going away.' "

Ware said the videotapes also shed light on the culture and the mindset of the insurgent groups. And he knows he's treading dangerous ground.

"I certainly go out there and expose myself. I've been to the safe houses. I surrender myself to their control. I've sat in living rooms face-to-face with these men," he said.

This explosion appears on one of the tapes passed to Ware.
"Maybe I am too close to all of this. I've been this close, and it terrifies me. It terrifies me on a personal level and it terrifies me in terms of what we are up against. This is far more serious, far more organized, committed, than many of us realized."

Ware denies he's being used by terror groups and said he filters what he learns, regardless of the source.

''This kind of thing is never easy or comfortable," he said. "It doesn't sit well with you as a human being on many levels. But that's what covering a war is like: It has two sides. I feel an obligation to discover as much as I can about both sides. I feel that's what we're here to do."

He is concerned that he may be getting too close to the insurgents and that one day they may decide to shoot the man who helps them get their message out.

"I worry about that every waking moment and every sleeping dream," he said. "It terrifies me. Terrifies me on a personal level and it terrifies me in terms of what we are up against."

07-07-2004, 20:46
This reporter is being interviewed right now on MSNBC. 21:45 CST

07-08-2004, 07:48

That should answer your question on "what type of optics" would you use.:D

07-08-2004, 09:52
Interesting. An AFP crew filmed the tag end of the attacks, and an AP TV crew arrived late. They were both tipped to the attacks in advance.

The film crews then incited the crowd to do that thing it did with the bodies. Sweet people, the media. Always looking to put American soldiers on TV -- regular or extra crispy.

This of course, raises the question, was the film of the mission planning taken by an Ali Baba cameraman as this reporter implies, or is it pro video shot by, say, AFP?

That's not as far-fetched as it sounds. Remember the missile attack on the DHL Airbus? A still photographer from Paris Match, and a TV news crew, whose affiliation I forget but it wasn't Al-Jazeera or Arabiya, participated in that terrorist act.

The media picked sides in this war, as usual. And they picked the enemy side, again as usual.



Roguish Lawyer
07-08-2004, 10:30

Good to have you here. Welcome!